| Arthur I. Boreman, 1863-1869 | Herman Guy Kump, 1933-1937 |
| Daniel D. T. Farnsworth, 1869 | Homer A. Holt, 1937-1941 |
| William E. Stevenson, 1869-1871 | Matthew M. Neely, 1941-1945 |
| John J. Jacob, 1871-1877 | Clarence W. Meadows, 1945-1949 |
| Henry M. Mathews, 1877-1881 | Okey L. Patteson, 1949-1953 |
| Jacob B. Jackson, 1881-1885 | William C. Marland, 1953-1957 |
| E. Willis Wilson, 1885-1890 | Cecil H. Underwood, 1957-1961 |
| Aretas Brooks Fleming, 1890-1893 | William Wallace Barron, 1961-1965 |
| William A. MacCorkle, 1893-1897 | Hulett C. Smith, 1965-1969 |
| George W. Atkinson, 1897-1901 | Arch A. Moore Jr., 1969-1977 |
| Albert B. White, 1901-1905 | John D. Rockefeller IV, 1977-1985 |
| William M. O. Dawson, 1905-1909 | Arch A. Moore Jr., 1985-1989 |
| William E. Glasscock, 1909-1913 | William Gaston Caperton III, 1989-1997 |
| Henry D. Hatfield, 1913-1917 | Cecil H. Underwood, 1997-2001 |
| John J. Cornwell, 1917-1921 | Robert E. Wise Jr., 2001-2005 |
| Ephraim F. Morgan, 1921-1925 | Joseph Manchin III, 2005-2010 |
| Howard M. Gore, 1925-1929 | Earl Ray Tomblin, 2010-present |
| William G. Conley, 1929-1933 | |